E

Excalibur Collision

4.7 of 5100 reviewsGoogle
excaliburcollision.com

Right now

August–October: 1 complaint in 4 public reviews.

Public reviews and 1–2★ reviews per month, last 15 months
MonthPublic reviews1–2★
August 202550
September 202520
October 202520
November 202530
December 202550
January 202650
February 202600
March 202640
April 202600
May 202610
June 202610
July 202610
August 202610
September 202620
October 202611

Too few public reviews to compare with the usual level. Reviews in the last three months: 4, at least 30 needed. Reviews in the year before: 29, at least 60 needed.

Tailwind Reliability ScoreA+
93/ 100

2.0% of collected reviews are 1–2★ (2 of 100)

Replied to 100% of 1–2★ reviews (2 of 2)

Practice questions answered: 0 of 6

Order counts, replies and practices are shown as facts and do not change the score.

How the score is computed →

Issue Rate

2.0%

2 of 100 reviews are 1–2★

5★
96
4★
2
3★
0
2★
0low
1★
2low

Track record not connected

A business can connect its order system to show how many jobs it completed, next to its public reviews — and, if it sends more, how its customers rated them and whether it is improving. The system sends monthly totals only, no customer data; Tailwind computes the figures by one method for everyone.

Is this your business? Claim it to connect

Common problems in Auto — and Excalibur Collision’s numbers

Fixed problem taxonomy across collected reviews, always with denominators.

Communication & customer support

18%

of negative reviews in Auto

This business: 1.0% of all reviews (1 of 100)

How can a customer reach a person who can resolve an issue, and how quickly do you respond?

No official response from the business yet.

Examples where an issue happened — and how the business responded

Replied to 2 of 2 1–2★ reviews (100%)
JG

Jeremiah Garcia

October 4, 2026Google
1/5

DAMAGED MY CAR AND VERY DISAPPOINTING SERVICE I brought my Porsche Macan here after two accidents about a month apart. I specifically pointed out several scratches and was told they could be repaired. After the second accident, which involved the vehicle being sideswiped, the shop kept my car for about 10 days. When I picked it up, no one walked around the vehicle with me, reviewed the repairs, or explained the invoice. I was simply asked to pay and handed my keys. For approximately $5,000, I expected much better workmanship and customer service. After getting home and inspecting the vehicle closely, I found multiple problems: • Several scratches we discussed were not repaired. • There were scrapes on the hood/paint-protection film. • There were scratches I did not notice before dropping the car off. • Black paint was left on the passenger door handle. • Some areas that were supposed to be repaired were still missing paint. • There was significant overspray/splatter along the side of the vehicle. I think they did this on purpose to get more business. I contacted the shop and returned so they could address the problems. During that visit, the shop acknowledged several issues. I was told the splatter was overspray from their work, paint had dripped onto the door-handle area, and some missing paint had simply been overlooked. They agreed to correct the problems. The overspray was successfully removed, which I appreciate. However, paint was still visible underneath the door handle, and some areas appeared to have simply been touched up rather than properly repaired. The final result still did not look professional or factory-quality. I also had questions about the invoice and labor charges. Instead of simply explaining them, the owner responded, “You obviously need me to show you the charges in person.” Some of the labor times also concerned me. The hood was billed at approximately 3.6 hours of paint labor, while the more visibly damaged fender was billed at approximately 1.6 hours. Door-handle removal labor also differed from one side to the other. I am including photos of the damage and invoice so others can review the charges for themselves. Mistakes happen, but there were too many issues with this repair. More importantly, I gave the shop an opportunity to correct them and was still dissatisfied with the finished work. My advice if you use this shop: Take detailed photos and videos before leaving your vehicle, get every requested repair in writing, review the invoice carefully, and inspect the vehicle in good lighting before paying and leaving. I cannot recommend this shop based on my experience. Spending approximately $5,000, finding multiple obvious problems, returning for corrections, and still being unhappy with the workmanship was extremely frustrating. Going forward, I will take my Porsche to a dealership.

The business replied on Google · October 13, 2026

We’re sorry to hear you were dissatisfied with your experience. We take our customers’ concerns seriously and have made efforts to address the issues you brought to our attention. However, we respectfully disagree with several of your claims regarding the vehicle’s condition. The concerns involving the hood’s paint-protection film and existing scratches were discussed, and we explained that the film’s peeling and discoloration were consistent with age and prolonged outdoor exposure. Not all pre-existing cosmetic concerns were related to the accident repairs performed. We also tried to find a reasonable solution by offering additional exterior detailing beyond the original repair work. Unfortunately, our conversations became increasingly unproductive, despite our attempts to resolve your concerns. We stand behind our work and believe respectful communication is essential to reaching a fair resolution. We appreciate the opportunity to have addressed your concerns and wish you the best moving forward.

Social & Web Discussions
ThreadsRedditXTikTokInstagramFacebookYouTube

Discussions about Excalibur Collision on social media

Found a thread, video, or forum post discussing Excalibur Collision? Paste any public link (Threads, Reddit, X, TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, LinkedIn, forums, or press) to post it directly onto this board.

No social discussions have been linked yet — paste the first public thread or video above.

Latest reviews

JG

Jeremiah Garcia

October 4, 2026Google
1/5

DAMAGED MY CAR AND VERY DISAPPOINTING SERVICE I brought my Porsche Macan here after two accidents about a month apart. I specifically pointed out several scratches and was told they could be repaired. After the second accident, which involved the vehicle being sideswiped, the shop kept my car for about 10 days. When I picked it up, no one walked around the vehicle with me, reviewed the repairs, or explained the invoice. I was simply asked to pay and handed my keys. For approximately $5,000, I expected much better workmanship and customer service. After getting home and inspecting the vehicle closely, I found multiple problems: • Several scratches we discussed were not repaired. • There were scrapes on the hood/paint-protection film. • There were scratches I did not notice before dropping the car off. • Black paint was left on the passenger door handle. • Some areas that were supposed to be repaired were still missing paint. • There was significant overspray/splatter along the side of the vehicle. I think they did this on purpose to get more business. I contacted the shop and returned so they could address the problems. During that visit, the shop acknowledged several issues. I was told the splatter was overspray from their work, paint had dripped onto the door-handle area, and some missing paint had simply been overlooked. They agreed to correct the problems. The overspray was successfully removed, which I appreciate. However, paint was still visible underneath the door handle, and some areas appeared to have simply been touched up rather than properly repaired. The final result still did not look professional or factory-quality. I also had questions about the invoice and labor charges. Instead of simply explaining them, the owner responded, “You obviously need me to show you the charges in person.” Some of the labor times also concerned me. The hood was billed at approximately 3.6 hours of paint labor, while the more visibly damaged fender was billed at approximately 1.6 hours. Door-handle removal labor also differed from one side to the other. I am including photos of the damage and invoice so others can review the charges for themselves. Mistakes happen, but there were too many issues with this repair. More importantly, I gave the shop an opportunity to correct them and was still dissatisfied with the finished work. My advice if you use this shop: Take detailed photos and videos before leaving your vehicle, get every requested repair in writing, review the invoice carefully, and inspect the vehicle in good lighting before paying and leaving. I cannot recommend this shop based on my experience. Spending approximately $5,000, finding multiple obvious problems, returning for corrections, and still being unhappy with the workmanship was extremely frustrating. Going forward, I will take my Porsche to a dealership.

The business replied on Google · October 13, 2026

We’re sorry to hear you were dissatisfied with your experience. We take our customers’ concerns seriously and have made efforts to address the issues you brought to our attention. However, we respectfully disagree with several of your claims regarding the vehicle’s condition. The concerns involving the hood’s paint-protection film and existing scratches were discussed, and we explained that the film’s peeling and discoloration were consistent with age and prolonged outdoor exposure. Not all pre-existing cosmetic concerns were related to the accident repairs performed. We also tried to find a reasonable solution by offering additional exterior detailing beyond the original repair work. Unfortunately, our conversations became increasingly unproductive, despite our attempts to resolve your concerns. We stand behind our work and believe respectful communication is essential to reaching a fair resolution. We appreciate the opportunity to have addressed your concerns and wish you the best moving forward.

MG

Mindy Greer

September 24, 2026Google
5/5

Chuck and his team were amazing!!! They did a great job on my repairs. They were courteous and very professional. I would recommend Caliber Collision Downtown Frisco to all my friends and family!!!

The business replied on Google · September 25, 2026

Mindy, we’re thrilled Chuck and the team delivered top-notch repairs with professionalism and courtesy. Our crew takes pride in making sure every job meets these high standards!

5★ Post Card
RC

Roy Chadbourn

September 17, 2026Google
5/5

Nick and Alex are the best and always take care us

The business replied on Google · September 18, 2026

Roy, thanks so much for the 5-star review! We're thrilled to hear that Nick and Alex always take great care of you. We truly appreciate your continued support and look forward to seeing you at Excalibur Collision Center next time!

5★ Post Card
See all 100 reviews

Reviews on platforms

  • Google4.7100 reviews1–2★: 2

Reliability

93/100A+

2.0% of collected reviews are 1–2★ (2 of 100)

Replied to 100% of 1–2★ reviews (2 of 2)

Practice questions answered: 0 of 6

Order counts, replies and practices are shown as facts and do not change the score.

How the score is computed →
Excalibur Collision
2.0%

of 100 reviews

Auto
7.6%
All businesses on Tailwind
7.9%
Website Embed & Trust Badge

Embed the Tailwind Reliability Score widget for Excalibur Collision on your website

Show visitors the order count reported by the business, the share of 1–2★ reviews among collected reviews, and the Tailwind Reliability Score — with the same denominators as on this page.

https://excaliburcollision.com
93/100
Excalibur CollisionTailwind Reliability Score · A+

★ 4.7 · 100 collected public reviews · 1–2★: 2.0% (2 of 100 collected reviews)

Collected reviews with dates
<!-- Tailwind Reliability Score widget -->
<div data-tailwind-widget="excalibur-collision" data-layout="score-ai" data-theme="light" data-lang="en"></div>
<script async src="https://tailwind.reviews/embed/widget.js"></script>

5★ Rating Calculator

4.7★ · 100 reviews

How many consecutive 5★ reviews Excalibur Collision needs to reach its next rating target

Target rating:
5★ reviews needed (→ 4.8★)+50

One new 1★ review requires +13 five-star reviews to recover 4.7★.

Where these numbers come from

Reviews and “Right now”

Public reviews from Google, collected by Tailwind.

pulse-v1

Methods are fixed before anything is computed and are never changed retroactively. A business cannot hide an inconvenient figure or buy a different calculation.

Frequently asked questions

What is Excalibur Collision's rating and real issue rate?

Across 100 collected public reviews, Excalibur Collision has an average rating of 4.7/5 and a 1–2★ complaint rate of 2.0% (2 of 100 reviews). For comparison, the industry average issue rate is 7.6%. Its Tailwind Reliability Score is 93/100.

What are the most common customer complaints about Excalibur Collision?

Among 2 negative (1–2★) reviews for Excalibur Collision, the most frequent complaint categories are: Communication & customer support (1 of 100 collected reviews, 1%); Damaged items or surfaces (1 of 100 collected reviews, 1%); Unexpected charges or price changes (1 of 100 collected reviews, 1%).

Does Excalibur Collision respond to negative reviews and complaints?

Excalibur Collision has publicly replied to 2 out of 2 negative (1–2★) reviews (100% response rate).

More companies in Auto

Subscribe to our newsletter

We send helpful materials once a month, along with information about discounts and special offers. No daily spam

We use your email only to send this newsletter. You can unsubscribe at any time from the link in every email. See our Privacy Policy.

How to unsubscribe from the mailing list?