C

Carmel Auto Repair

4.9 of 5100 reviewsGoogle
carmelautorepair.com

Right now

August–October: 1 complaint in 48 public reviews.

Public reviews and 1–2★ reviews per month, last 15 months
MonthPublic reviews1–2★
August 202500
September 202500
October 202500
November 202500
December 202500
January 202600
February 202600
March 202600
April 2026161
May 2026140
June 2026101
July 2026121
August 202671
September 2026230
October 2026180

Too few public reviews to compare with the usual level. Reviews in the year before: 52, at least 60 needed. Months with reviews in the year before: 4, at least 6 needed.

Tailwind Reliability ScoreB+
87/ 100

4.0% of collected reviews are 1–2★ (4 of 100)

Replied to 75% of 1–2★ reviews (3 of 4)

Practice questions answered: 0 of 6

Order counts, replies and practices are shown as facts and do not change the score.

How the score is computed →

Issue Rate

4.0%

4 of 100 reviews are 1–2★

5★
92
4★
4
3★
0
2★
0low
1★
4low

Track record not connected

A business can connect its order system to show how many jobs it completed, next to its public reviews — and, if it sends more, how its customers rated them and whether it is improving. The system sends monthly totals only, no customer data; Tailwind computes the figures by one method for everyone.

Is this your business? Claim it to connect

Common problems in Auto — and Carmel Auto Repair’s numbers

Fixed problem taxonomy across collected reviews, always with denominators.

Communication & customer support

18%

of negative reviews in Auto

This business: 1.0% of all reviews (1 of 100)

How can a customer reach a person who can resolve an issue, and how quickly do you respond?

No official response from the business yet.

Examples where an issue happened — and how the business responded

Replied to 3 of 4 1–2★ reviews (75%)
JM

Jenn Meadows

August 9, 2026Google
1/5

Mathew I thought really saved my day come to find out after looking at my receipt charged me for tire disposal when I only gave them a rim. Charged me another 15.45 for roadside hazard which I did not ask for. Will not recommend this place when they overcharged and took advantage of me.

The business replied on Google · August 7, 2026

Wow, thank you for sharing such a glowing review! 😊 We're delighted that Mathew could help you out and turn your day around. It's wonderful to know that our team provided you the outstanding service you deserved. Whenever you need us, we're eagerly here to assist!

JF

Jacob Freiberger

July 15, 2026Google
1/5

Decided to give them my business and have them replace the clutch and flywheel in my mustang. I live an hour away from their location. Took my car there and was told the parts would be in in a few days and the repair would be done on that same day. After not hearing from them for almost a week I called and they said they didn't receive the right parts and it would be a couple more days. Almost a whole week later I call and they say it should be done in the next day or so. Finally it's done after almost 2 weeks and I pick it up just to find they didn't calibrate or set the sensor on the flywheel. So in the middle of my 1 hour drive home, it starts misfiring and driving bad. Due to traffic and the time I had to go home. Took it to the local ford dealership and they set the sensor right and got my car good. This could have messed up my car. When I called them and told them about it, I spoke with Aaron and he was quick to get smart and tell me what I "should have done." Well what should have been done is THEY should have done the job right to begin with and completed the job. Especially after spending over $4000 with them. They create excuses and when they don't do the job right they won't stand by their work. Don't go here.

The business replied on Google · July 16, 2026

Hi Jacob, Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. We're genuinely sorry that you left feeling disappointed. You originally brought your Mustang to us for a clutch and flywheel replacement, and that repair was completed. Before the vehicle left our shop, everything related to that repair was checked and operating as expected. We understand that after you picked up the vehicle, another concern arose during your drive home. While we cannot determine the cause without inspecting the vehicle, we have never refused to help. In fact, because your Check Engine light was on, we also offered to perform an inspection and diagnostic to determine exactly what was causing the issue and whether it was related to the repair or a separate concern. Aaron invited you to bring the Mustang back so our technicians could inspect the vehicle and make things right if the issue was connected to our work. Unfortunately, to the best of our knowledge, the vehicle was never returned for us to evaluate. We stand behind our work and remain willing to inspect the vehicle and assist in resolving your concern. Please contact Aaron directly, and we'll be happy to schedule a time to look everything over. We appreciate your feedback, as it helps us continue improving our communication and service. — The Carmel Auto Repair Team 👨‍🔧💚

Social & Web Discussions
ThreadsRedditXTikTokInstagramFacebookYouTube

Discussions about Carmel Auto Repair on social media

Found a thread, video, or forum post discussing Carmel Auto Repair? Paste any public link (Threads, Reddit, X, TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, LinkedIn, forums, or press) to post it directly onto this board.

No social discussions have been linked yet — paste the first public thread or video above.

Latest reviews

BM

Bonface Mupereki

October 17, 2026Google
5/5

Good mechanics are hard to find. Honest ones are even harder. Glad I found this place.

The business replied on Google · October 17, 2026

Hello! We're really grateful you found us and appreciate your trust in our team. It's so rewarding to be recognized for our honesty and skill, which we strive for with every customer. Thanks for choosing us and we look forward to helping you whenever you need us!

5★ Post Card
GD

GUSTAVO DANIEL NUÑEZ REQUEJO

October 17, 2026Google
5/5

The heat in my car stopped working and with winter coming I definitely couldn't ignore it. They diagnosed the problem, called me before doing the repair, and explained what it was going to cost. I gave them the okay and got the car back later. Heat works perfectly now. My wife is probably happier about that than I am.

The business replied on Google · October 17, 2026

Hi! We're really glad you brought your car to us for repairs, and it warms our hearts to hear that the heating is now running smoothly. It's truly our pleasure to assist you, and we hope your family's rides are cozier now. Thank you for your kind words, and know that we're here for anything else you might need in the future!

5★ Post Card
CF

Carlos Fsv

October 16, 2026Google
5/5

Not every maintenance item is urgent. They actually took the time to separate the 'do it now' stuff from the 'keep an eye on it' stuff. Very helpful.

The business replied on Google · October 16, 2026

Hi Carlos! We’re really glad you found our approach helpful and that we were able to provide you with clear advice. Your feedback is wonderful to hear, and we’re so grateful for your trust. Wishing you many safe and happy miles!

5★ Post Card
See all 100 reviews

Reviews on platforms

  • Google4.9100 reviews1–2★: 4

Reliability

87/100B+

4.0% of collected reviews are 1–2★ (4 of 100)

Replied to 75% of 1–2★ reviews (3 of 4)

Practice questions answered: 0 of 6

Order counts, replies and practices are shown as facts and do not change the score.

How the score is computed →
Carmel Auto Repair
4.0%

of 100 reviews

Auto
7.6%
All businesses on Tailwind
7.9%
Website Embed & Trust Badge

Embed the Tailwind Reliability Score widget for Carmel Auto Repair on your website

Show visitors the order count reported by the business, the share of 1–2★ reviews among collected reviews, and the Tailwind Reliability Score — with the same denominators as on this page.

https://carmelautorepair.com
87/100
Carmel Auto RepairTailwind Reliability Score · B+

★ 4.9 · 100 collected public reviews · 1–2★: 4.0% (4 of 100 collected reviews)

Collected reviews with dates
<!-- Tailwind Reliability Score widget -->
<div data-tailwind-widget="carmel-auto-repair" data-layout="score-ai" data-theme="light" data-lang="en"></div>
<script async src="https://tailwind.reviews/embed/widget.js"></script>

5★ Rating Calculator

4.9★ · 100 reviews

How many consecutive 5★ reviews Carmel Auto Repair needs to reach its next rating target

5★ reviews needed (→ 4.9★)Target reached

One new 1★ review requires +40 five-star reviews to recover 4.9★.

Where these numbers come from

Reviews and “Right now”

Public reviews from Google, collected by Tailwind.

pulse-v1

Methods are fixed before anything is computed and are never changed retroactively. A business cannot hide an inconvenient figure or buy a different calculation.

Frequently asked questions

What is Carmel Auto Repair's rating and real issue rate?

Across 100 collected public reviews, Carmel Auto Repair has an average rating of 4.9/5 and a 1–2★ complaint rate of 4.0% (4 of 100 reviews). For comparison, the industry average issue rate is 7.6%. Its Tailwind Reliability Score is 87/100.

What are the most common customer complaints about Carmel Auto Repair?

Among 4 negative (1–2★) reviews for Carmel Auto Repair, the most frequent complaint categories are: Communication & customer support (1 of 100 collected reviews, 1%); Lateness or rescheduling (1 of 100 collected reviews, 1%); Unexpected charges or price changes (1 of 100 collected reviews, 1%).

Does Carmel Auto Repair respond to negative reviews and complaints?

Carmel Auto Repair has publicly replied to 3 out of 4 negative (1–2★) reviews (75% response rate).

More companies in Auto

Subscribe to our newsletter

We send helpful materials once a month, along with information about discounts and special offers. No daily spam

We use your email only to send this newsletter. You can unsubscribe at any time from the link in every email. See our Privacy Policy.

How to unsubscribe from the mailing list?