C

Auto

Car Care Auto & Tire

4.4 of 591 reviewsGoogle
carcareautoandtire.com

Right now

No public reviews in August–October.

Public reviews and 1–2★ reviews per month, last 15 months
MonthPublic reviews1–2★
August 202511
September 202500
October 202500
November 202500
December 202531
January 202610
February 202610
March 202630
April 202600
May 202600
June 202610
July 202630
August 202600
September 202600
October 202600

Too few public reviews to compare with the usual level. Reviews in the last three months: 0, at least 30 needed. Reviews in the year before: 13, at least 60 needed.

Tailwind Reliability ScoreWeak
44/ 100
Public reviews (14.3% 1–2★)39
Problem resolution & replies (62% · 8/13)+5
Industry practices (0/6)+0

Issue Rate

14.3%

13 of 91 reviews are 1–2★

5★
73
4★
4
3★
1
2★
2low
1★
11low

Track record not connected

A business can connect its order system to show how many jobs it completed, next to its public reviews — and, if it sends more, how its customers rated them and whether it is improving. The system sends monthly totals only, no customer data; Tailwind computes the figures by one method for everyone.

Is this your business? Claim it to connect

Common problems in Auto — and Car Care Auto & Tire’s numbers

Fixed problem taxonomy across collected reviews, always with denominators.

Communication & customer support

18%

of negative reviews in Auto

This business: 1.1% of all reviews (1 of 91)

How can a customer reach a person who can resolve an issue, and how quickly do you respond?

No official response from the business yet.

Examples where an issue happened — and how the business responded

Replied to 8 of 13 1–2★ reviews (62%)
DL

Dan London

April 26, 2024Google
1/5

I had a code for a recall for my Hyundai 2011. They stated my tire was rotating like a potato not a circle, and I would lose my tire while driving if I continued like this. This was as ridiculous as it sounded, and I did not need a entirely new transmissions as confirmed by 3 shops following. My car runs fine besides the recall for fuel emissions. They could not resolve the recall code, and told me I needed to bring it to the Hyundai Dealership, understandable. I was charged $180 for this service. If you feel that is fair, go here, I will not be. Edit: I see you replied. This is not my name. I prefer to remain anonymous, look up my vehicle if you want my name to confirm these claims, I'm sure your DB holds few 2011 Hyundai Accents. Please do not tell me what to do. This is the customer service that led to my 1 star review. EDIT part II: Last response I will give, I wasn't there in the last month. Real great investigation work only searching a month back. You scanned my VIN in order to enter me in as a new customer into your system. I hope you have a great life, but you are overcharging for services that are not needed.

The business replied on Google · April 4, 2024

Greetings, per your request, we have checked our database and in the last month, we have only serviced 1 car that was a 2011. It was not a Hyundai. I believe you may have our shop confused with another shop. Feel free to call us at 610-459-2886 for clarification. Additionally we do not SCAN VIN numbers to enter a customer. You started out talking about a code, then went to a tire, then a transmission and finally a recall. Our charge for looking at any vehicle is NOT $180.00, so you were not at our shop at all. You also do not have a receipt from us either showing the work done as every real customer has. We have been providing quality service in the area for over 40 years and will continue to do so, however, we did not provide any services or opinions to you whatsoever. Had we done so, you would have had written estimates, a receipt and if you had a recall, we would have provided you that written information. You can always provide us here with an invoice number if you'd like to prove me wrong :-/ As for recalls, only dealerships perform recall repair. Your story is rambling and you simply have mistaken our shop for another.

JR

Jesse Redick

July 13, 2023Google
2/5

Got full synthetic oil change for $85 after a very long time of talking him down from the original quote of $150. He then went on to explain how I need 4k in car repairs (some were valid, some werent- like telling me I have two broken axels because I need an alignment). When he realized I wasn't gonna leave him my car for the list of repairs, he started explaining how he's actually just a business man and was hired less than a year ago to 'bring this company into the 21st century'. To me, seems like the actual owner might have once cared about his customers, but this businessman is exactly that- a business man.

The business replied on Google · July 31, 2023

In response to your 2 star rating we would like to share the actual version of events as follows. You came in for a full synthetic oil change. Our company charged you $20.00 to perform an oil change plus the oil (4.86 quarts at $11.97/Quart) and the cost of the filter of $16.58. The oil change price was $94.75, NOT $150.00! You mentioned that the Jiffy Lube had a lower price because you had a coupon. So we called Jiffy Lube to verify the cost and matched the price and charged you $79.71 plus tax. For the oil change. During our courtesy inspection of the vehicle, which we do on every vehicle that we service, we found that you had several issues that needed to be brought to your attention. *Your Front and Rear Brakes were very low and we recommended replacing them as we should! * We discussed that you may have hit something because your LEFT FRONT STRUT and RIGHT REAR SHOCK are BENT and they needed to be replaced which is a safety issue! Obviously we recommend replacing Struts and Shocks in pairs and we gave you pricing to reflect the cost of replacing your shocks and struts as we should! *Because the shocks are damaged, they were obviously affecting your tires which we showed you. The tires were wearing unevenly and were choppy because of the broken shock absorbers which obviously is also a severe safety issue that needed to be corrected. And so we reported to you that they NEEDED to be replaced. *During our courtesy inspection, we found that your check engine light was on and needed to be diagnosed to determine the issue? *We also suggested that you replace your cabin air filter because the one you had was clogged with dirt and debris! When we notice things like that, we obviously report that to the vehicle owner. The fact that you chose to not have that changed was up to you. All we did was report it to you. *Due to damage, your left front axle was leaking oil and it needed to be replaced as that is a very serious safety issue. *Your coolant level was low and we told you that you needed to figure out where the coolant was leaking from. We Recommend a Pressure test to find the leaks. You simply declined all the work! We checked over your vehicle and told you of the issues which is mandatory for a service repair facility to do. Your car is in need of repair! You should fix it! As for your statement of “...he started explaining how he's actually just a business man and was hired less than a year ago to 'bring this company into the 21st century'. To me, seems like the actual owner might have once cared about his customers, but this businessman is exactly that- a business man.” Your response seems very “snide” as if a business should not have a central point of focus. The owner does care about the customers and wants to have them experience a professional shop that performs quality work. After over 40 years in business, we’re building a new shop and we needed an experienced business manager to handle the day to day operations which is a VERY GOOD business decision and just about every business has someone that is in charge of operations. We also have a person in charge of the actual repairs being performed. We are pleased and proud that we hired and have a competent business manager on staff to assure that the shop runs efficiently and affords us the ability to let our Tech’s focus on quality auto repair. We also are proud of the many 5 star reviews on Google and SureCritic and your 2 star review does not accurately reflect our shop. *YOU CAME IN FOR AN OIL CHANGE. *WE FOUND MANY SAFETY ISSUES AND REPORTED THEM TO YOU AS WE SHOULD HAVE. *THEY WERE ALL REAL ISSUES THAT NEEDED TO HAVE ATTENTION APPLIED TO THEM AND WE HOPE YOU GIVE YOUR CAR *THE ATTENTION IT DESERVES AND PLEASE BE AWARE THAT MOST OF THESE ISSUES ARE SAFETY ISSUES. *PLEASE BE CAREFUL AND GET THE VEHICLE REPAIRED SOON. If you decide to have the work done by us, we will gladly offer you a discount on the work and 1 free oil change as well.

Social & Web Discussions
ThreadsRedditXTikTokInstagramFacebookYouTube

Discussions about Car Care Auto & Tire on social media

Found a thread, video, or forum post discussing Car Care Auto & Tire? Paste any public link (Threads, Reddit, X, TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, LinkedIn, forums, or press) to post it directly onto this board.

No social discussions have been linked yet — paste the first public thread or video above.

Latest reviews

DM

debbie morrison

July 13, 2026Google
5/5

No written review

ML

Margaret Lally

July 13, 2026Google
5/5

Always fast and courteous service! Mike and the staff are the best!

5★ Post Card
SE

Steven Ente

July 1, 2026Google
5/5

Mike and Stephen were absolutely amazing for me going above and beyond when my car broke down right by their shop. They drove by where my car was checked on it helped with free replacement did tests were so generous all while I was far from home with food in my car. Have nothing but amazing things to say about this place

The business replied on Google · July 1, 2026

Thanks Steven for the kind review! We knkow it sucks when you're a long way from home and you break down (or your car breaks down... Often they happen together :-) ) I'm glad your problem happened pretty close to our shop and it was our pleasure to help. After 45 years in the neighborhood repairing cars, its still about service over sales. Happy 4th!!!!

5★ Post Card
See all 91 reviews

Reviews on platforms

  • Google4.491 reviews1–2★: 13

Reliability

44/100Weak
Review base39 pts
Order scale+0 pts
Problem resolution+5 pts
Industry practices+0 pts
Car Care Auto & Tire
14.3%

of 91 reviews

Auto
7.6%
All businesses on Tailwind
7.9%
Website Embed & Trust Badge

Embed Car Care Auto & Tire’s Reputation & Trust Widget on Your Website

Display live verified metrics, true issue rate, and your Tailwind Score directly on your homepage or checkout.

https://carcareautoandtire.com
14/100
Car Care Auto & TireTailwind Score · Mixed

★ 4.4 · 91 public reviews analyzed · 14.3% 1–2★

Ask AI about this business
<!-- Tailwind Reputation Widget -->
<div data-tailwind-widget="carcareautoandtire-com" data-layout="score-ai" data-theme="light" data-lang="en"></div>
<script async src="https://tailwind.reviews/embed/widget.js"></script>

5★ Rating Calculator

4.4★ · 91 reviews

How many consecutive 5★ reviews Car Care Auto & Tire needs to reach its next rating target

Target rating:
5★ reviews needed (→ 4.5★)+19

One new 1★ review requires +6 five-star reviews to recover 4.4★.

Where these numbers come from

Reviews and “Right now”

Public reviews from Google, collected by Tailwind.

pulse-v1

Methods are fixed before anything is computed and are never changed retroactively. A business cannot hide an inconvenient figure or buy a different calculation.

Frequently asked questions

What is Car Care Auto & Tire's rating and real issue rate?

Across 91 collected public reviews, Car Care Auto & Tire has an average rating of 4.4/5 and a 1–2★ complaint rate of 14.3% (13 of 91 reviews). For comparison, the industry average issue rate is 7.6%. Its Tailwind Reliability Score is 44/100.

What are the most common customer complaints about Car Care Auto & Tire?

Among 13 negative (1–2★) reviews for Car Care Auto & Tire, the most frequent complaint categories are: Damaged items or surfaces (2 reviews, 2.2% of all reviews); Communication & customer support (1 reviews, 1.1% of all reviews); Unexpected charges or price changes (1 reviews, 1.1% of all reviews).

Does Car Care Auto & Tire respond to negative reviews and complaints?

Car Care Auto & Tire has publicly replied to 8 out of 13 negative (1–2★) reviews (62% response rate).

More companies in Auto

Subscribe to our newsletter

We send helpful materials once a month, along with information about discounts and special offers. No daily spam

We use your email only to send this newsletter. You can unsubscribe at any time from the link in every email. See our Privacy Policy.

How to unsubscribe from the mailing list?