A

Bars / Restaurants

Aleko's

4.8 of 5500 reviewsGoogle
alekosvillagecafe.com

Right now

August–October: 0 complaints in 18 public reviews.

Public reviews and 1–2★ reviews per month, last 15 months
MonthPublic reviews1–2★
August 202520
September 202550
October 2025100
November 202560
December 2025100
January 2026101
February 202680
March 202690
April 2026150
May 2026131
June 2026161
July 2026140
August 202690
September 202690
October 202600

Too few public reviews to compare with the usual level. Reviews in the last three months: 18, at least 30 needed.

Tailwind Reliability ScoreAverage
56/ 100
Public reviews (2.8% 1–2★)52
Problem resolution & replies (50% · 7/14)+4
Industry practices (0/6)+0

Issue Rate

2.8%

14 of 500 reviews are 1–2★

5★
435
4★
43
3★
8
2★
4low
1★
10low

Track record not connected

A business can connect its order system to show how many jobs it completed, next to its public reviews — and, if it sends more, how its customers rated them and whether it is improving. The system sends monthly totals only, no customer data; Tailwind computes the figures by one method for everyone.

Is this your business? Claim it to connect

Common problems in Bars / Restaurants — and Aleko's’s numbers

Fixed problem taxonomy across collected reviews, always with denominators.

Communication & customer support

17%

of negative reviews in Bars / Restaurants

This business: 0.2% of all reviews (1 of 500)

How can a customer reach a person who can resolve an issue, and how quickly do you respond?

No official response from the business yet.

Examples where an issue happened — and how the business responded

Replied to 7 of 14 1–2★ reviews (50%)
MA

Mark

January 13, 2026Google
2/5

We got there Saturday around 6 and were seated right away and thankful because we did not make a reservation. We sat for a bit and talked and since it was very busy we expected a bit of a wait which was perfectly fine. The waiter came over and we placed an order for two appetizers and went ahead and put dinner in. The menu at the restaurant is about HALF the size of the online menu at THEIR website. No Moussaka, Italian subs and many many other dishes. There was no children's menu at the restaurant but the online had 6 great items including a mini Gyro. We asked for a kids menu and the waiter replied they didn't have one....no burgers, no mini Gyros just chicken tenders and mozzarella sticks. NOT kid friendly. One of my grand kids got the chicken Kabob plater which was dry hardly season chicken on 3 skewers on top of dry white rice ($17.95). My other grandson ended up getting soup and French fries. The drinks came out. 16 oz Diet Cokes at $3.75 each in a 16 oz bottle, but we were given glasses with ice. Here comes the food...all of it at the same time. They set it down and walked away without leaving us one piece of silverware or napkins. I raised my voice so the waiter could hear me and we tried several times to get his attention. We finally (after 5-10 minutes) walked up to the bar and told the woman there (owner???) and she brought them over. While she was there we discovered they forgot one Diet Coke and an order of fries. The spanakopita was about the size of a deck of cards and was burnt! Well we just went ahead and ate it anyway. No one ever checked on us and when dinner was done my grandson asked for cheesecake. We had seen a piece go by in a small plastic container but decided to try it anyway. They were out. Ok that happens...busy night. The bill: The cheese cake was still on it and the waiter said he removed it...It was not and was $11.95! The late diet Cole came from behind the bar so they charged us liquor tax! No one had liquor! He refunded that in cash. I must say the Gyros were good and we ordered the platters ($16.95) and the only other item that was there was an order of fries about the size of a small McDonalds. Final word: The worst part was the menu in the restaurant only has about half the items listed on their site. It felt like a bait and switch! So two kids and three adults and the bill was $165.57 including the tip that was added with the cheese cake still on the bill!!

The business replied on Google · January 13, 2026

Hello Mark, I'm very sorry for your poor experience. I would love the opportunity to make up your experience at the restaurant. Please email me directly through the website so we can offer you the proper experience. If I may just explain the menu. We have a new dinner menu at the sit down Alekos, but still offer everything that the carry out offered. Our current dinner menu does offer all the kids meals that we had at the carryout including the mini Gyro, Grilled cheese, Vegi mini gyro and we added a mini kbob meal. I reviewed your transaction and a refund was issued in the amount of $12.61. Please let me know via email if you did not receive the refund. Once again, please allow us the opportunity to offer you the proper experience. Joana@alekosvillagecafe.com

KK

Kevin Koldaro

August 4, 2023Google
2/5

So the food is ok. Compared to Greek places I’m disappointed. The service at the counter is horrible and unfriendly. The food is average. Don’t order the rice pudding, over 5$ and get two little scoops. Food here is def overpriced!!! Was super excited to find this place and was really disappointed ☹️

The business replied on Google · August 4, 2023

Dear Kevin, I'm so sorry the food was not to your expectation. I would really appreciate additional feedback so we can help correct the behavior and make the experience up to you. We work hard to have 100% satisfaction. call the store and ask for the manager. We hope to serve you in the future and give you the excellent experience we aim for! Kevin, I found your transaction and refunded your order. Please give us a try in the future, I have addressed this with my staff member. Once again we apologize

Social & Web Discussions
ThreadsRedditXTikTokInstagramFacebookYouTube

Discussions about Aleko's on social media

Found a thread, video, or forum post discussing Aleko's? Paste any public link (Threads, Reddit, X, TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, LinkedIn, forums, or press) to post it directly onto this board.

No social discussions have been linked yet — paste the first public thread or video above.

Latest reviews

IF

Ilan Farrar

September 23, 2026Google
5/5

Best Greek food there is, not just in Middletown, but Hagerstown and Frederick as well.

5★ Post Card
DG

Daniel Greenberg

September 22, 2026Google
5/5

No written review

TG

todd glesner

September 17, 2026Google
5/5

Lamb shank lamb shank lamb shank

5★ Post Card
See all 500 reviews

Reviews on platforms

  • Google4.8500 reviews1–2★: 14

Reliability

56/100Average
Review base52 pts
Order scale+0 pts
Problem resolution+4 pts
Industry practices+0 pts
Aleko's
2.8%

of 500 reviews

Bars / Restaurants
11.7%
All businesses on Tailwind
7.9%
Website Embed & Trust Badge

Embed Aleko's’s Reputation & Trust Widget on Your Website

Display live verified metrics, true issue rate, and your Tailwind Score directly on your homepage or checkout.

https://alekosvillagecafe.com
3/100
Aleko'sTailwind Score · Mixed

★ 4.8 · 500 public reviews analyzed · 2.8% 1–2★

Ask AI about this business
<!-- Tailwind Reputation Widget -->
<div data-tailwind-widget="alekosvillagecafe-com" data-layout="score-ai" data-theme="light" data-lang="en"></div>
<script async src="https://tailwind.reviews/embed/widget.js"></script>

5★ Rating Calculator

4.8★ · 500 reviews

How many consecutive 5★ reviews Aleko's needs to reach its next rating target

Target rating:
5★ reviews needed (→ 4.9★)+501

One new 1★ review requires +19 five-star reviews to recover 4.8★.

Where these numbers come from

Reviews and “Right now”

Public reviews from Google, collected by Tailwind.

pulse-v1

Methods are fixed before anything is computed and are never changed retroactively. A business cannot hide an inconvenient figure or buy a different calculation.

Frequently asked questions

What is Aleko's's rating and real issue rate?

Across 500 collected public reviews, Aleko's has an average rating of 4.8/5 and a 1–2★ complaint rate of 2.8% (14 of 500 reviews). For comparison, the industry average issue rate is 11.7%. Its Tailwind Reliability Score is 56/100.

What are the most common customer complaints about Aleko's?

Among 14 negative (1–2★) reviews for Aleko's, the most frequent complaint categories are: Communication & customer support (1 reviews, 0.2% of all reviews); Lateness or rescheduling (1 reviews, 0.2% of all reviews).

Does Aleko's respond to negative reviews and complaints?

Aleko's has publicly replied to 7 out of 14 negative (1–2★) reviews (50% response rate).

More companies in Bars / Restaurants

Subscribe to our newsletter

We send helpful materials once a month, along with information about discounts and special offers. No daily spam

We use your email only to send this newsletter. You can unsubscribe at any time from the link in every email. See our Privacy Policy.

How to unsubscribe from the mailing list?