← Back to Roto All Day Cafe score

5 reviews for Roto All Day Cafe

SM

sondra machtel

November 10, 2026Google
1/5

I have heard such great things about the food here so i gave it a try. first time i ordered the banana foster latte and the crispy chicken salad sandwich, and received the correct latte but completely wrong sandwich. i looked back at the receipt later on and noticed it was actually rung up wrong but the cashier “Bee” paid full attention when she asked me to tip and quickly noticed how much and gave me a lovely attitude!! i did not have time to go back to get a new sandwich, otherwise i would’ve, so i ate it and gave benefit of the doubt. it was very good, however this was not what i wanted. and i didn't need an attitude after i ordered, especially when it was done incorrectly. im now writing this review after my second order, and this time i was charged for both a latte and sandwich but only received a latte. I was charged for BOTH but i told only a latte was ordered. somehow they forget a $18 sandwich but not my $7 latte. of course this time happens to be a delivery order so i cant go there and now i am without the sandwich that i paid for! soooo weird! I wish more attention would’ve been placed when taking a patrons order rather than focusing on how much they may or may not they tip. the disappointment i feel is immeasurable. this is now the second time a food item has been wrong or in this case not here! i choose to support this cafe because its a local biz and the food is really good, when you can actually get it! hopefully something will change bc as of now i am certainly NOT recommending any one i know to come here and received a half-assed order. these experiences are making me think this place is a scam. do better Roto!

EM

Emily Martin

November 8, 2026Google
5/5

No written review

JC

justina caliendo

November 8, 2026Google
5/5

Roto Cafe is genuinely one of my favorite spots for coffee and food. I’m here at least twice a week, which says a lot about how much I enjoy this place! What really stood out was Devon and the way he went above and beyond to make our experience great. His attentiveness, professionalism, and genuine effort made the entire experience exceptional. Employees like Devon are what make a business stand out. He deserves recognition (and honestly, a raise!). Thank you, Devon, for going the extra mile. Roto is lucky to have you!

5★ Post Card
JA

Joseph A. Pascal

November 4, 2026Google
5/5

Not being hyperbolic when I say Roto is the best spot for Lunch on Long Island. Sandwiches are exquisite, Wine list is on point. The staff is what makes this place. Staff on 11/4 around 2pm TOP NOTCH. This place keeps getting better with every visit.

5★ Post Card
AG

Aaron Greenwald

November 4, 2026Google
5/5

Roto All Day Cafe is an absolute gem in Bay Shore! Great food, fantastic atmosphere, and the kind of place you immediately want to come back to. Everything feels fresh, thoughtfully prepared, and full of flavor. The Gobbler Sandwich is a must-try in the Fall season. Absolutely delicious, incredibly satisfying, and easily one of the best sandwiches around. Worth coming back for that alone! It's great to have a spot like Roto in Bay Shore. Highly recommend supporting this local gem. Five stars all around!

5★ Post Card

Subscribe to our newsletter

We send helpful materials once a month, along with information about discounts and special offers. No daily spam

We use your email only to send this newsletter. You can unsubscribe at any time from the link in every email. See our Privacy Policy.

How to unsubscribe from the mailing list?