Court Whitfield
November 11, 2026GoogleVery disappointing experience with informed consent and client communication We brought our young cat in for dental surgery after weeks of significant oral pain. We were told the veterinarian would call after bloodwork and dental X-rays to discuss findings and treatment options. Instead, approximately 15 minutes after drop-off, while we were still driving home, the veterinarian recommended removing every tooth based solely on a visual examination and suspected stomatitis. The promised diagnostic tests had not been performed. We weren't opposed to full-mouth extraction if medically necessary. We simply wanted to understand why such an irreversible procedure was warranted and whether a less extensive approach was possible. When we requested ten minutes to discuss the recommendation privately, the veterinarian expressed discomfort proceeding. Despite clarifying that we wanted to make an informed decision, not refuse treatment, we were told we were "not a good fit," and our cat's surgery was canceled. The practice also cited an earlier scheduling interaction in which we expressed frustration about our cat potentially waiting another month in pain. It was troubling to see our concern for his welfare characterized as problematic client behavior. To the business manager's credit, he listened, explained the recommendation more thoroughly, and apologized. We genuinely appreciated his professionalism and ability to discuss our concerns respectfully without becoming defensive. The outcome is what makes this experience particularly frustrating. One week later, another veterinary practice performed a comprehensive dental examination with X-rays. They identified significant tooth resorption, root infections, and bone loss. They extracted ten affected teeth and preserved the remaining teeth. Although they expressed concern about possible future stomatitis, they did not establish it as a current diagnosis requiring full-mouth extraction. Because the original procedure was canceled, our cat endured another week of significant dental pain and difficulty eating. Our complaint was never about the veterinarian recommending full-mouth extraction. It was about being expected to authorize an irreversible procedure before the diagnostic evaluation we'd been promised, then having our request for clarification treated as grounds to discontinue care. Unfortunately, the veterinarian never discussed her recommendations with us in person. We left feeling that our efforts to make an informed medical decision were treated as an inconvenience rather than responsible pet ownership. We understand that veterinary professionals encounter difficult clients and deserve appropriate professional boundaries. However, we were direct and respectful in our questions. Requesting clarification and informed consent should not be confused with hostility. Ultimately, we were told we weren't a good fit for their practice. Given how our concerns were handled, we concluded that this practice wasn't a good fit for us either. We respect veterinarians' clinical judgment and their right to decline procedures they consider inappropriate. But informed consent requires meaningful communication, not unquestioning agreement. Unfortunately, we cannot recommend this practice based on our experience. I would give a one-star rating, but the business manager's professionalism earns a second star.
The business replied on Google · November 11, 2026
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. We are sorry that your experience with our hospital did not meet your expectations. We understand how difficult and emotional it can be to hear that a young pet may require extensive dental extractions, particularly when the recommendation involves an irreversible procedure. We would like to clarify a few points regarding Spike's care. During his initial examination, our Doctor found that he was exhibiting significant oral pain. Based on his age, clinical presentation, and oral findings, juvenile periodontitis and stomatitis were among the primary concerns. We would also like to clarify why our Doctor contacted you before proceeding with anesthesia. During the intake process, your concerns and opposition to full-mouth extraction had already been communicated to our technician. Because we take informed consent seriously, our Doctor made the decision to contact you before anesthetizing Spike. We did not want to proceed with anesthesia, complete the evaluation, and potentially find ourselves in a situation where significant diseased or painful teeth needed to be removed but the owners were unwilling to authorize the recommended treatment. Our intention was to ensure everyone understood the potential treatment plan before proceeding. It is important to clarify that full-mouth extraction was not the predetermined treatment plan regardless of the diagnosis. Juvenile periodontitis and stomatitis are different conditions with different treatment approaches. If Spike's dental radiographs and examination under anesthesia supported juvenile periodontitis the treatment would have been to remove only the affected teeth. However if the findings supported stomatitis, full mouth extraction would be the recommended treatment. Becaused you had already expressed opposition to full-mouth extraction during intake, our Doctor wanted to discuss this possibility before proceeding with anesthesia to ensure there was an understanding and agreement about the potential treatment recommendations. During that conversation, concerns about full-mouth extraction were expressed multiple times, and partial extractions were proposed as an alternative. Our Doctor took time to explain why she did not recommend that approach in a patient with suspected stomatitis. Partial extractions can leave behind the source of ongoing inflammation, prolong pain, and ultimately require additional procedures. We have a responsibility to recommend treatment that offers the best opportunity for a successful outcome and lasting pain relief. We cannot knowingly leave painful or diseased teeth behind when doing so would compromise a patient's comfort and long-term outcome. We absolutely respect a client's right to ask questions, seek clarification, obtain a second opinion, and take time to consider medical recommendations. Those are important parts of informed decision-making. Our decision to discontinue care was not simply because you requested time to discuss the recommendation privately. It was based on a fundamental disagreement regarding the treatment we felt was medically appropriate and our inability to reach agreement on a treatment plan our Doctor was comfortable providing. We would never want to proceed with surgery when there is such a significant disagreement about the intended treatment and its goals. At Paw & Purr, our responsibility is to advocate for our patients and recommend the treatment we believe is medically appropriate, even when those recommendations are difficult to hear. We understand that clients may seek different opinions or choose a different course of treatment, and we respect their right to do so. However, we will always prioritize our patients' comfort, well-being, and long-term health in the medical decisions we make. We are glad that Spike was able to receive treatment elsewhere and we sincerely hope he is recovering comfortably and that his oral pain has been relieved.