177 reviews for More Ice Cream

Good ice cream served by friendly staff. Located in a former Lutheran personage. Excellent choice if you aren't into one of the big chains.

No written review

Update: Return visit. Staff was so great that I had to add another couple stars. Very interesting and atmospheric. Our server was very nice. The ice cream is good enough, and my dog liked her puppy cup.

Visited this place with my family and we all loved it. Definitely will be back

No written review

Amazing ice cream and the price is great. They have a nice selection of flavors and toppings. The building is really nice, it looks like an old ice cream parlor. The owner is also very nice.

No written review

Great ice cream!

One scoop of ice cream and one brownie, no whipped cream, no cherry. Two orders of one scoop and one brownie almost 19 dollars??? YIKES.

The ice cream was amazing! The young lady who scooped for our family this afternoon was so sweet and kind. My daughters loved her hair and vibe. The only negative was not being able to tip with a credit card.

No written review

Ice cream is wonderful and so is the setting! We were so delighted to find it open so late in October.

No written review

No written review

Fabulously. Delicious Triple chocolate peanut butter ice cream.

Great ice cream but website shouldn't say open if they are not, we drove from Clarksburg to here and found it closed!

No written review

June 28, 2024 - Middletown has a great ICE CREAM parlor along the Old National Pike, called More Ice Cream! My wife and I lived across the mountain years ago in Keedysville, Middletown is halfway , on our routine trips into Frederick. Usually we’d stop for gas, or building supplies, or lunch at the Main Cup. . . so we’re thrilled for this Ice Cream parlor. 1st time for us stopping in with our Grandkids for dessert, at More’s. Opened in 2014 by Jim Kehoe. Originally this spot was a Lutheran Parish house, built in 1848. Thank you Jim . . . for incorporating the original structure of the home ! As a former American History teacher, I love the nostalgic photos of Middletown’s high school heroes up on the walls of your ice cream shop! Of course , the many flavors of Garber’s (1912) Ice Cream are wonderful! Our group included 3 generations , no problem selecting our favorite flavors of ice cream! Your high school staff were helpful & professionals! Our daughter from rival Urbana high school remembered her field hockey games against Middletown girls , a tough rivalry! Then out to the big “wrap around” porch to enjoy our desserts! Our little 2 & 4 year old Grandkids liked playing in the side yard. Felt safe away from the Main street traffic. Thank you ! We’ll certainly stop in again for More Ice Cream , on our way into Middletown, MD😃👍🏼 🍦 Ice Cream Licks 🍦 Did you know . . . . . ? *More Ice Cream is on Oldest U.S. road, National Pike , constructed 1811 - 1834 *Scholars suggest frozen treats traced to 550 BCE to Persians ( sharbat, Gelato) *Marco Polo’s travels to Asia , 13th century, Discovered “ milk ice” from Kublai Khan *1700 Maryland Royal Gov. served ice cream *George Washington & Tom Jefferson would have ice cream at their homes *Jefferson 1st President to serve ice cream *1846 Nancy Johnson invents new ice cream hand crank machine *1851 Jacob Fussell starts 1st U.S. ice cream business Save (tummy)room when visiting More’s Ice Cream in Middletown, MD 😃👍🏼🍦

+14

My wife and Daughter stopped for ice cream not knowing they were closed, a man let them in and my daughter got her ice cream, thank you for making my kids day!!! Your kindness didn't go unnoticed!!!

No written review