← Back to Cagan Management Group, Inc. score

5 reviews for Cagan Management Group, Inc.

JP

James Pozzie

October 13, 2026Google
1/5

I've been renting for over 10 years and this is by far the worst management company I've ever dealt with. From lack of responding in a timely manner, to ignoring our AC maintenance request for 22 days during the summer. From charging us for repairs from damaged caused by a previous tent please advise before renting from one of their Illinois properties. Document everything and anything you can or you'll pay for it in the end.

CA

Charlotte Allen

September 30, 2026Google
1/5

I've lived at a Cagan property in Chicago since August of 2025, and I renewed my lease in April of 2026. Unfortunately, a month later in May, a recurring cockroach problem popped up. The issue has yet to be remedied after three rounds of exterminator treatment. My maintenance woman has been great to work with in trying to resolve the issue, but the management team hasn't been the most helpful. All I feel like they want is a rent check from me every month and don't care about their tenants living with bugs. I'm investigating my rights under the Chicago RLTO. This photo collage doesn't even encapsulate how many bugs I've found in my unit in the last 4 months.

IC

Isabella C

September 28, 2026Google
1/5

This is my first time working with a management company for rental purposes. Cagan is absolutely atrocious, believe the reviews you see. Seek other companies that are far more organized and communicative. My unit was entered twice in one week without notice, I have a pet in my unit and did not approve nor was aware that someone was coming to my unit. When confronted about the situation they mentioned it was an "innocent mistake". They lack response in emails and over the phone and maintenance issues are never tended to in a timely manner. Respectfully, save yourself the stress and find another unit with another company.

JH

Josh H

September 11, 2026Google
1/5

Unprofessional. Terrible customer service. Would not recommend, save yourself the headache.

M

M

April 27, 2026Google
2/5

This was the worst property management experience I have had. 922 North Blvd in Oak Park is managed by Cagan, had recurring roach problems and visible mold in the laundry room. The fire alarm system was not properly serviced and triggered approximately eight false alarms in only three months (very pleasant when you have an anxious dog and an alarm goes off at 1am before work the next day). The bones of the building are old, steam heat from the 70s heats the building. When a part of the heating system broke, it took 2 months for replacement, causing us to live with out heat for two months and a sky high electric bill. Once it was fixed the heat remained unadjustable, blasting 85 degrees in the apartment, which is not feasible for comfortability or leaving a pet home alone. Vacant apartments were not heated, and a steam leak caused by the low temperatures in one vacant unit flooded the apartment below and displaced residents. In my experience, these serious health, safety, and maintenance issues were not handled with the urgency, communication, or accountability they required. Prospective tenants should ask for documentation regarding pest control, mold remediation, fire-alarm inspections, heating reliability, emergency procedures, and how resident complaints are addressed. Cagan Management is a slum lord. 922 North Blvd in Oak Park should be condemned, but alas profit matters more human health and safety.

Subscribe to our newsletter

We send helpful materials once a month, along with information about discounts and special offers. No daily spam

We use your email only to send this newsletter. You can unsubscribe at any time from the link in every email. See our Privacy Policy.

How to unsubscribe from the mailing list?